Furlan R, Brambilla E, Sanvito F, Roccatagliata L, Olivieri S, Bergami A, Pluchino S, Uccelli A, Comi G, Martino G. Vaccination with amyloid-beta peptide induces autoimmune encephalomyelitis in C57/BL6 mice. Brain. 2003 Feb;126(Pt 2):285-91. PubMed.
Recommends
Please login to recommend the paper.
Comments
Brigham and Women's Hospital Harvard Medical School
The authors show inflammation in the CNS following use of pertussis and immunization with Aβ. Their ability to induce an EAE-type response in C57/Bl6 mice when it wasn’t seen in AβPP-transgenic mice may relate not only to the use of pertussis, but to the fact that AβPP-transgenic mice may have a form of immunologic tolerance to Aβ due to the overexpression of Aβ (Monsonego et al., 2001). One would like to have seen the adoptive transfer of an EAE-like picture with Aβ-reactive T cells in the absence of pertussis.
It does seem a likely hypothesis that the adverse events observed in the Elan trial were related to a Th1-type response against Aβ induced by the adjuvant (Weiner and Selkoe, 2002). Of note, T cell reactivity to Aβ has not been documented in patients with AD. However, in extensive ongoing studies in our laboratories, we have found such T cell reactivity and are in the process of characterizing it—something that will be required should further vaccination trials be attempted in AD. The human result does not mean that Aβ vaccination cannot be attempted if modifications of the immunization protocol are made. This includes immunizing with fragments of Aβ to obtain only antibody responses, or immunizing in a fashion that does not induce Th1 type responses. We are planning the latter approach in humans by using the mucosal route to administer Aβ, inducing both antibodies and Th2/Th3 responses rather than Th1 responses (Monsonego et al., 2000). We also postulate that, in addition to antibodies, T cells which secrete cytokines such as TGF-β may also be of benefit in AD.
References:
Monsonego A, Maron R, Zota V, Selkoe DJ, Weiner HL. Immune hyporesponsiveness to amyloid beta-peptide in amyloid precursor protein transgenic mice: implications for the pathogenesis and treatment of Alzheimer's disease. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2001 Aug 28;98(18):10273-8. PubMed.
Weiner HL, Selkoe DJ. Inflammation and therapeutic vaccination in CNS diseases. Nature. 2002 Dec 19-26;420(6917):879-84. PubMed.
Weiner HL, Lemere CA, Maron R, Spooner ET, Grenfell TJ, Mori C, Issazadeh S, Hancock WW, Selkoe DJ. Nasal administration of amyloid-beta peptide decreases cerebral amyloid burden in a mouse model of Alzheimer's disease. Ann Neurol. 2000 Oct;48(4):567-79. PubMed.
View all comments by Howard WeinerThe key point of the Furlan et al. paper is that they used pertussis toxin as a necessary adjuvant to produce the autoimmune encephalitis; that is not the protocol of others who carried out Aβ vaccination experiments in transgenic mice. The results are nevertheless of considerable interest to EAE and possibly multiple sclerosis. In their discussion, the authors state that "this experimental evidence may explain the unexpected appearance of clinical signs consistent with CNS inflammation occurring in 15 patients with Alzheimer's disease undergoing the Aβ vaccination trial." Many physicians would disagree that the encephalitis cases were unexpected, and would contend that the surprising result was that only 15 came down with symptoms.
References:
McGeer PL, McGeer E. Is there a future for vaccination as a treatment for Alzheimer's disease?. Neurobiol Aging. 2003 May-Jun;24(3):391-5. PubMed.
View all comments by Pat McGeerThis paper is interesting. Pertussis toxin mimics certain aspects of bacterial inflammation and enhances traffic of T cells into the CNS, thereby favoring EAE-type inflammatory responses. One could speculate that some of the trial subjects may have harbored subclinical inflammatory responses, perhaps associated with AD, that contributed to vaccine sequelae.
It is good to see that more attention is being given to the immunogenicity of the peptide/HL-A complexes. A better outcome would be wonderful, but active immunization of AD patients at this stage of our understanding of the disease remains risky.
View all comments by Harvey CantorNYU school of Medicine
The adverse reactions of vaccines can have various and complex origins related to both the antigen and/or the adjuvant. We have previously addressed concerns about the use of full-length Aβ in vaccines, but adjuvants can also add to the toxicity of the preparation. Humoral and cell-mediated immune responses have side effects, and are enhanced by adjuvants to a different degree. These immunostimulatory additives may also activate a latent infection in the patient, and have the potential to promote amyloidosis, particularly when administered with an amyloidogenic peptide (Sigurdsson et al., 2002). Their selection depends on what the vaccine is designed to accomplish. An enhanced cellular immune response is important to combat various microorganisms, whereas antibody-mediated effects may be more appropriate to promote clearance of self-antigens, such as the Aβ peptide.
The article by Roberto Furlan and colleagues indicates that vaccination with Aβ in Freund’s adjuvant may induce encephalomyelitis in mice when coadministered with pertussis toxin (PT). Based on the known properties of PT, this vaccine combination could be expected to generate a T-1-type immune response which, among other things, results in the activation of macrophages, cytotoxic T-lymphocytes (CTLs), and high levels of IgG2a antibodies. The authors point out that the mouse encephalitis observed in their studies might resemble the cerebral inflammation seen in some of the AD patients receiving the Elan vaccine AN-1792, in which QS-21 served as an adjuvant. Although the cause of the adverse effects in the clinical trial remains to be determined, it is interesting to note similarities in the properties of these two adjuvants. Like PT, QS-21 promotes a T-1 type response and, in mice, both are associated with an increase in complement-fixing antibodies, such as IgG2a (Kensil et al., 1995). Related to this type of response, PT induces CD4+ T-cells as shown by Furlan and colleagues, whereas QS-21 elicits both a CD4+ and a CD8+ effect in various species (Kensil et al., 1995). Interestingly, most CTLs are CD8+, suggesting that QS-21 may have a more pronounced CTL effect than PT. In designing vaccines for promoting Aβ clearance, it is obviously important to avoid a CTL induction, and any detrimental complement activation. As we discussed previously, adjuvants stimulating a T-2 type response such as alum may be more appropriate for human vaccination with Aβ derivatives (Sigurdsson et al., 2001). These adjuvants promote predominantly a humoral immune response, which is more likely to lead to Aβ clearance without the potentially destructive effects of CTLs.
References:
Sigurdsson EM, Wisniewski T, Frangione B. Infectivity of amyloid diseases. Trends Mol Med. 2002 Sep;8(9):411-3. PubMed.
Kensil CR, Wu JY, Soltysik S. Structural and immunological characterization of the vaccine adjuvant QS-21. Pharm Biotechnol. 1995;6:525-41. PubMed.
Sigurdsson EM, Scholtzova H, Mehta PD, Frangione B, Wisniewski T. Immunization with a nontoxic/nonfibrillar amyloid-beta homologous peptide reduces Alzheimer's disease-associated pathology in transgenic mice. Am J Pathol. 2001 Aug;159(2):439-47. PubMed.
View all comments by Blas FrangioneMichigan State University
I’d like to note two additional things that might have relevance here. First, there is a severe neurological response when another protein is coadminstered with PT (myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein, or MOG25-35) that seems much greater than that observed with Aβ. Second, the sequence for Aβ in mice differs from the human sequence. I am a little concerned whether the response the authors are observing is actually against endogenous murine Aβ (unlikely, as murine Aβ is mostly intracellular in nontransgenic mice) or AβPP (not very common in white matter or the leptomeninges). It would have been interesting to evaluate other proteins that provoke a strong immune reaction in this model, for example, the nonmammalian keyhole limpet hemocyanin, with PT to see if this is a nonspecific T cell response against myelin and CNS vessels whenever a strong immunogenic protein is used. In other words, the PT plus adjuvant may not be the most relevant control group to imply specificity of the response for Aβ as opposed to other immunogenic peptides.
Conversely, an excessive T cell response is precisely what Elan claims is responsible for the problem they observed in the five percent of vaccinated patients who exhibited signs of CNS inflammation. For this reason they are planning further study with vaccines that have less of a T cell response.
Another option would be to evaluate passive antibody immunotherapy, as this should totally lack T cell activation. Until Elan releases more information about the cases that had adverse reactions, it will be difficult to know if the model described here is relevant to human AD cases.
View all comments by Dave MorganMake a Comment
To make a comment you must login or register.